Today, Bonny and Kym and I want to talk about all the strange little rules…
Read With Us: The John of John Promo Post

Every book club has that author.
The one whose writing sparks conversations that were unexpected and meaningful. The one whose characters stay with you long after you’ve finished the final page. The one who somehow brings readers together, even when they all come away with different interpretations.
For the Read With Us group, that author is Douglas Stuart.
When we read Shuggie Bain, something clicked. The discussions were thoughtful, emotional, and deeply personal in a way that doesn’t happen with every book. We found ourselves talking not just about the novel, but about family, resilience, love, addiction, identity, and what it means to survive difficult circumstances without losing your humanity.
So when John of John was published, choosing it for our September online book club felt like the easiest decision Bonny, Kym and I could have made.

Like Stuart’s previous novels, John of John is driven by unforgettable characters and extraordinary prose. Set on a remote Scottish island, it’s a story about family, belonging, and the ties that shape us—for better or worse. It’s literary fiction at its finest: emotionally rich, beautifully observed, and filled with the kind of moments that make you stop reading for a minute just to absorb what you’ve read.
Like Shuggie Bain and Young Mungo, the writing is gorgeous but also accessible. I also want you know that, while John of John explores many of the same themes of family, identity, and belonging, it’s not nearly as emotionally punishing. Douglas Stuart is still going to make you feel things, it’s still moving, still beautifully written, and still full of complex family relationships—but it leaves a little more room for hope. I appreciated that, and I think many of you will too.
We’ll be discussing John of John on Tuesday, September 15th on Zoom at 7pm. There’s still plenty of time to get your hands on a copy and read along with us.
I have a feeling Douglas Stuart is about to bring us together all over again.
Discover more from Carole Knits
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.




























Still in the library’s queue for this book…hopefully it will come to me in time. I listened to the audio preview and had a difficult time with the accents, so I don’t think that would work for me….
Complex family relationships but “not nearly as emotionally punishing” is why this is my favorite of Douglas Stuart’s novels!
I am just about to settle in with my reread of this book! (I will listen and read along this time!) I think the setting is perfection for this story to unfold. And the sheep… and the weaving (literal and figurative!) And the characters… yes, they are simply so beautiful!